"Tears of Redemption" follows Mercer, a man who sets out to avenge the murder of his mentor, Lucas, who took him in after his parents were killed by street gang. Mercer travels across the Western frontier to kill Elias, leader of the gang who killed Lucas, only to mistakenly kill Elias' son who has the same name and likeness as Elias. Mercer thinks that revenge has been earned only to discover that the stakes have only exploded as Elias amasses an even bigger gang to go after Mercer, his love interest Olivia and the very town he tried to protect.