Toys are meant to be played with, but sometimes they get thrown away when the newness wears off. Mr. Bibbs's job is to clean an old thrift store, but when he discovers a box of misfit toys collecting dust in a dark corner, he's surprised that no one has kept them safe. There's a bear, ballerina, mouse, general, and more to discover. Pondering how to fix and find them a new home, he whisks the toys away and into the trunk of his car. Will he have the skills to renew the toys to their original glory, or will they be left collecting dust forever?